BLACK FRIDAY    |    Discounts up to 40%    |    Use discount code  BLACK20    | Valid until 30 November 2026

How to Choose and Buy Diamonds Online

Published: 2023-08-07
Edited: 2026-11-13
Airidas Ulevičius
Airidas Ulevičius
Founder and Director of Auksinė svajonė, Master Jeweller

You can safely buy diamonds online if you don’t rely solely on a photo and the price. Before buying, check the report from an independent gemological laboratory, compare the 4Cs, view a 360° image or video of the specific stone, make sure the diamond is natural or lab-grown, and read the seller’s return and shipping policies in advance.

In short: How can you safely buy a diamond online?

Before paying for a diamond or a piece of diamond jewelry, check the following:

  • whether it is clearly stated whether the diamond is natural or lab-grown;
  • whether a report from an independent gemological laboratory is provided, if you’re buying a single, higher-value stone;
  • whether you can verify the report number in the laboratory’s database;
  • whether you can see photos or a 360° view of the specific diamond you’re purchasing;
  • what its 4Cs are;
  • what the stone’s dimensions are in millimeters;
  • who the seller is and how to contact them;
  • What are the return, shipping, and insurance terms?
  • What information is provided about the jewelry itself if you’re buying a diamond that’s already set?

If any of these points are unclear, ask the seller additional questions before making a purchase.

Buying Diamonds Online: How Does It Differ from Shopping in a Store?

The main difference is simple—online, you can’t hold the diamond in your hands and compare several stones under different lighting conditions yourself. Therefore, your decision will largely be based on:

  • the lab report;
  • photos;
  • videos;
  • 360° views;
  • exact dimensions;
  • and information provided by the seller.

Online, you can quickly compare more options and specifications, but this requires the ability to distinguish meaningful information from a merely attractive product description.

1. First, decide what you’re actually buying

A loose diamond

In this case, you’re choosing a specific stone that can later be set in a ring or other piece of jewelry. The following are particularly important here:

  • laboratory reports;
  • specific stone specifications;
  • dimensions;
  • appearance;
  • identification number.

A piece of jewelry with a diamond

In this case, you need to evaluate not only the stone but also the entire piece:

  • gold fineness;
  • construction;
  • stone setting;
  • weight of the piece;
  • ring size, if you’re buying a ring;
  • overall design.

2. Set a budget before applying filters

The selection of diamonds online can be nearly endless. If you don’t set limits from the start, it’s very easy to begin with one budget and, after applying a dozen or so filters, end up looking at stones that are twice as expensive. Decide:

  • the maximum amount;
  • whether it’s intended solely for the stone;
  • whether it must cover the entire piece of jewelry;
  • which parameters are most important to you.

3. Check whether the diamond is natural or lab-grown

This is one of the most important things to know before you even start comparing prices. Natural and lab-grown diamonds are not the same in terms of origin, although lab-grown diamonds essentially have the same basic chemical, physical, and optical properties as natural diamonds.

Two stones that look similar can have very different origins, market positioning, and prices.

4. Diamond Certificate: What Should You Actually Check?

Buyers often use the term “diamond certificate.” It would be more accurate to refer to a diamond grading or evaluation report issued by an independent gemological laboratory. It may include:

  • carat weight;
  • color;
  • clarity;
  • cut data;
  • dimensions;
  • proportions;
  • polish;
  • symmetry;
  • fluorescence;
  • an inclusion map or other identifying information;
  • report number.

It is important to understand that such a report is not the same as a product description written by the seller.

Verify the report number

If a diamond has, for example, a GIA report, its number can be verified in the laboratory’s database. The information online must match the details in the document provided. If the seller only provides a blurry photo of the document but does not allow you to verify its number, it’s worth asking why.

Does the laboratory report indicate the diamond’s price?

Not necessarily. A gemological grading report describes the stone’s characteristics, but it should not be confused with a property appraisal or the determination of a specific market price.

5. The 4Cs are important, but they’re not enough online

Diamonds are evaluated based on four main criteria:

  • Cut;
  • Color;
  • Clarity;
  • Carat Weight.

When buying online, it’s more important to understand how to apply these numbers in practice:

4C Criteria What should you check online?
Cut Whether the grading, proportions, symmetry, and polish are listed
Color Whether the grade is clearly specified and what it is being compared to
Clarity Where the inclusions are and whether they are visible in the image
Carats Not just the weight, but also the actual dimensions in millimeters

Two diamonds with very similar 4C parameters may still look different to the eye. Therefore, the documentation and the image should complement each other. For more details, see the 4C Diamond Buying Guide.

6. Carats Are Not the Same as Apparent Size

A carat is a measure of weight, not the diameter of a diamond. Two stones of the same carat weight may have:

  • different dimensions;
  • different proportions;
  • different shapes;
  • different apparent sizes when viewed from above.

If you’re comparing several stones of the same shape and similar weight, comparing their dimensions can tell you a great deal about how they’ll look in a piece of jewelry.

7. Diamond shape and cut are not the same thing

These terms are often confused online. Shape refers to the outline of the diamond when viewed from above. For example:

  • round;
  • oval;
  • princess;
  • pear;
  • marquise;
  • emerald;
  • cushion.

The quality of the cut describes how the stone’s proportions and facets control the light.

If you haven’t decided on a shape yet, we won’t repeat the different options here—you can find them in the article "Diamond shapes. How to choose?"

8. Look for more than just a photo—seek out a 360° view

A studio product photo alone isn’t informative enough when choosing a more valuable diamond. Ideally, you should be able to see:

  • the specific stone from multiple angles;
  • a 360° view;
  • a high-resolution close-up;
  • a video.

Why? Because the lab report provides a classification, but it doesn’t convey everything you’ll see with your own eyes. A visual view allows you to better assess:

  • the visibility of inclusions;
  • the overall character of the stone;
  • the play of light;
  • darker zones characteristic of some elongated shapes;
  • the symmetry of the shape.

9. Compare prices only among similar diamonds

If one 1 ct diamond costs significantly less than another 1 ct diamond, that doesn’t automatically mean you’ve found a great deal. The price can be influenced by:

  • natural or lab-grown origin;
  • cut;
  • color;
  • clarity;
  • shape;
  • fluorescence;
  • proportions;
  • laboratory certificates;
  • whether the stone has been treated;
  • the seller’s services and warranties.

Therefore, don’t compare 1 ct to 1 ct; instead, compare stones of similar origin + similar cut + similar 4Cs + similar other parameters. Only then does the price difference make sense.

10. Check the seller

Even a good diamond certificate doesn’t make just any online store trustworthy. Before paying, check:

  • the company name;
  • contact information;
  • physical or registered address;
  • how long the company has been in business;
  • customer reviews;
  • whether a real consultant answers questions;
  • how payment is processed;
  • what the return policy is;
  • how high-value items are shipped.

If you’re buying an expensive diamond, a consultant’s reluctance to provide additional information is a worse sign than having to wait a little while for a response.

11. Read the return policy before you buy, not after

This is especially important when buying a diamond online. A screen doesn’t always accurately convey:

  • the shade of color;
  • the actual size;
  • the way the light plays off it;
  • how the piece looks on your hand.

Therefore, find out in advance:

  • whether the item can be returned;
  • within what timeframe;
  • what exceptions apply;
  • who covers the return shipping costs;
  • and whether different terms apply to custom-made or engraved items.

12. Check Shipping and Insurance

High-value jewelry isn’t just any ordinary package. Before buying, find out:

  • how the item is packaged;
  • whether the shipment is trackable;
  • whether the recipient’s signature is required;
  • how lost or damaged shipments are handled;
  • whether the shipment is insured.

Especially when buying from abroad, it’s also worth clarifying the delivery, tax, and return procedures in advance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safe to buy a diamond online?

Yes, if the seller is reputable, provides sufficient information about the specific diamond, allows you to verify documents from an independent laboratory, and has clear delivery and return terms.

How do I verify a diamond certificate?

First, check which laboratory issued the document. If the laboratory has an online report verification system, use the document number to compare the data provided there with the seller’s information.

Which is more important—a diamond certificate or a photo?

You need both. A laboratory report objectively describes the stone’s characteristics, while a high-quality image helps you understand what a specific diamond looks like. A document alone does not convey the full appearance, and a photo alone does not confirm the technical parameters.

Are 1-carat diamonds always the same size?

No. A carat indicates weight. Diamonds of the same weight can have different dimensions and appear to be different sizes due to their shape and proportions.

How can you tell if a diamond is natural or lab-grown?

This must be clearly stated in the product information and, where applicable, in the gemological laboratory’s reports. You cannot reliably determine its origin based on a simple photo alone.

Don’t base your choice on a single number

When buying a diamond online, the biggest mistake is simply looking for the highest carat weight at the lowest price. You’ll make a good choice when you consider the origin, lab reports, the 4Cs, dimensions, the specific appearance of the stone, and the seller’s credibility together.

If you’re looking for a ready-made piece of jewelry, check out “Auksinės Svajonės” premium jewelry with gemstones. If you’re choosing a diamond specifically for an engagement ring, it’s worth reading the guide to choosing an engagement ring.

Back

There are four main types of cookies used on the "Auksinė svajonė" website.

By continuing to browse, you agree to the necessary cookies. You may also agree to the use of other cookies. Detailed information about cookies and their usage is available in our Privacy Policy.